Execution on the White House Lawn

From Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia

(Difference between revisions)
Revision as of 14:20, 4 December 2007 (edit)
ABerkes (Talk | contribs)

← Previous diff
Current revision (16:30, 10 February 2009) (edit) (undo)
ABerkes (Talk | contribs)

 
(10 intermediate revisions not shown.)
Line 1: Line 1:
-There is a very persistent story that [[Thomas Jefferson]] ever shot anyone on the White House lawn for treason. This '''not true'''. The story originated in the movie ''Swordfish'' (2001), where it is mentioned by John Travolta's character, Gabriel Shear.+There is a very persistent story that [[Thomas Jefferson]] personally executed someone on the White House lawn for treason; some sites name the prisoner as a Rodney Cox from North Carolina.<ref>Robert Ludlum, [http://classicals.com/federalist/ThomasJeffersonhall/messages/780.html "Re: IS IT TRUE THAT HE SHOT A MAN AT THE WHITE HOUSE FOR TREASON?"] American History Forums: Thomas Jefferson Lecture Hall. Accessed February 10, 2009.</ref> We have no evidence that this event ever occurred: no such thing is ever mentioned in Jefferson's papers, or contemporary newspaper accounts. The story, as far as we know, originated entirely with the movie ''Swordfish'' (2001), where it is mentioned by John Travolta's character, Gabriel Shear.
-Jefferson never personally killed anyone, nor were there any treason executions or convictions during his presidency. Jefferson did help write a "Bill to Attaint Josiah Philips and Others" in 1778, which ordered the trial and provided for the execution of the murderer and bandit Josiah Philips for treason. Josiah Philips was eventually found and convicted of robbery, not treason.<ref>[[Short Title List|''PTJ'']] 2:189-193.</ref>+The true origins of the story are a puzzle. Several actual events could have been (severely) misunderstood or mistaken for a "Jefferson execution:"
 + 
 +*Jefferson was involved in drafting a "Bill to Attaint Josiah Philips and Others" in 1778, which ordered the trial and provided for the execution of the murderer and bandit Josiah Philips for treason. Josiah Philips was eventually found and convicted of robbery, not treason.<ref>[[Short Title List|''PTJ'']] 2:189-193.</ref>
 +*The murder of Alexander Hamilton by Aaron Burr in their famous 1804 duel has also been suggested as a possible source for the story in question.
 + 
 +Neither of the above seems very plausible as a source. Unless further reliable evidence surfaces, we can only explain this story as a complete fabrication by the scriptwriters of ''Swordfish.''
==Footnotes== ==Footnotes==
Line 7: Line 12:
==Further Sources== ==Further Sources==
-[http://movies.yahoo.com/movie/1804486105/details ''Swordfish'' on Yahoo! Movies]+*Coates, Eyler Robert. ''The Thomas Jefferson FAQ.'' [http://www.geocities.com/Athens/7842/archives/shooting.htm "DID JEFFERSON SHOOT A TRAITOR ON THE WHITE HOUSE LAWN?"]
 +*Internet Movie Database. [http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0244244/ ''Swordfish''].
 +*Jefferson Library. ''A Summary View.'' [http://jeffersonlibrary.wordpress.com/2008/11/05/jefferson-still-survives-unlike-the-other-guy/ "Jefferson still survives, unlike the other guy."] A brief discussion of this question in our library blog.
[[Category:Frequently Asked Questions]] [[Category:Frequently Asked Questions]]
[[Category:Politics]] [[Category:Politics]]
 +[[Category:Legends]]

Current revision

There is a very persistent story that Thomas Jefferson personally executed someone on the White House lawn for treason; some sites name the prisoner as a Rodney Cox from North Carolina.[1] We have no evidence that this event ever occurred: no such thing is ever mentioned in Jefferson's papers, or contemporary newspaper accounts. The story, as far as we know, originated entirely with the movie Swordfish (2001), where it is mentioned by John Travolta's character, Gabriel Shear.

The true origins of the story are a puzzle. Several actual events could have been (severely) misunderstood or mistaken for a "Jefferson execution:"

  • Jefferson was involved in drafting a "Bill to Attaint Josiah Philips and Others" in 1778, which ordered the trial and provided for the execution of the murderer and bandit Josiah Philips for treason. Josiah Philips was eventually found and convicted of robbery, not treason.[2]
  • The murder of Alexander Hamilton by Aaron Burr in their famous 1804 duel has also been suggested as a possible source for the story in question.

Neither of the above seems very plausible as a source. Unless further reliable evidence surfaces, we can only explain this story as a complete fabrication by the scriptwriters of Swordfish.

Footnotes

  1. Robert Ludlum, "Re: IS IT TRUE THAT HE SHOT A MAN AT THE WHITE HOUSE FOR TREASON?" American History Forums: Thomas Jefferson Lecture Hall. Accessed February 10, 2009.
  2. PTJ 2:189-193.

Further Sources