When governments fear the people, there is liberty...(Quotation)

From Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia

(Difference between revisions)
Revision as of 14:54, 14 August 2009 (edit)
ABerkes (Talk | contribs)
(other attributions added)
← Previous diff
Current revision (09:43, 15 December 2009) (edit) (undo)
ABerkes (Talk | contribs)

 
(2 intermediate revisions not shown.)
Line 3: Line 3:
'''Variations:''' '''Variations:'''
#"When governments fear the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny. [[Strongest reason for the people to...keep and bear arms...(Quotation)|The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to keep and bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government]]." #"When governments fear the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny. [[Strongest reason for the people to...keep and bear arms...(Quotation)|The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to keep and bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government]]."
 +#"Does the government fear us? Or do we fear the government? When the people fear the government, tyranny has found victory. The federal government is our servant, not our master!"
 +#“When the people fear the government, that's tyranny; when the government fears the people, that's freedom.”
'''Sources consulted:''' '''Sources consulted:'''
-Searching on the phrase "fear the people"+Searching on the phrase "fear the people," "government fear us," "fear the government," "tyranny has found victory," and "government is our servant"
 +#[http://rotunda.upress.virginia.edu:8080/founders/TSJN.html Papers of Thomas Jefferson Digital Edition]
#[http://www.monticello.org Monticello website] #[http://www.monticello.org Monticello website]
#[http://oll.libertyfund.org/?option=com_staticxt&staticfile=show.php%3Ftitle=1734 Ford's ''Works of Thomas Jefferson''] #[http://oll.libertyfund.org/?option=com_staticxt&staticfile=show.php%3Ftitle=1734 Ford's ''Works of Thomas Jefferson'']
Line 15: Line 18:
-'''Earliest known appearance in print:''' 1993<ref>Gyeorgos Ceres Hatonn, ''Programming, Pitfalls, and Puppy-Dog Tales'' (Author, 1993), [http://books.google.com/books?id=MJDJim0HdVcC&pg=PA60&dq=%22When+the+people+fear+the+government,+there+is+tyranny.%22&lr=&client=firefox-a 60].</ref>+'''Earliest known appearance in print:''' 1914<ref>John Basil Barnhill, [http://library.indstate.edu/about/units/rbsc/debs/pamph-b.html ''Barnhill-Tichenor Debate on Socialism, As It Appeared in the National Rip-Saw.''] Saint Louis, Mo.: The National Rip-Saw Pub. Co., 1914, 34.</ref>
<ref>To establish the earliest appearance of this phrase in print, the following sources were searched for the phrase, "When governments fear the people, there is liberty": Google Books, Google Scholar, Amazon.com, Internet Archive, JSTOR, American Broadsides and Ephemera, American History and Culture Online: Sabin Americana, 1500-1926, Early American Imprints, Series I: Evans (1639-1800), Early American Imprints, Series II: Shaw-Shoemaker (1801-1819), Eighteenth Century Collections Online, The Making of the Modern World: The Goldsmiths'-Kress Library of Economic Literature, America's Historical Newspapers, 19th Century United States Newspapers, American Founding Era Collection.</ref> <ref>To establish the earliest appearance of this phrase in print, the following sources were searched for the phrase, "When governments fear the people, there is liberty": Google Books, Google Scholar, Amazon.com, Internet Archive, JSTOR, American Broadsides and Ephemera, American History and Culture Online: Sabin Americana, 1500-1926, Early American Imprints, Series I: Evans (1639-1800), Early American Imprints, Series II: Shaw-Shoemaker (1801-1819), Eighteenth Century Collections Online, The Making of the Modern World: The Goldsmiths'-Kress Library of Economic Literature, America's Historical Newspapers, 19th Century United States Newspapers, American Founding Era Collection.</ref>
Line 24: Line 27:
'''Status:''' We have not found any evidence that Thomas Jefferson said or wrote, "When governments fear the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny," or any of its listed variations. '''Status:''' We have not found any evidence that Thomas Jefferson said or wrote, "When governments fear the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny," or any of its listed variations.
-'''Comments:''' One source attributes this quotation to Thomas Jefferson in ''The Federalist.''<ref>Archimedes C. Articulo, ''The Experience of Philosophy'' (Manila, Philipines: Rex Book Store, 2008), [http://books.google.com/books?id=EqyBOV6NY8oC&pg=PT334&dq=%22When+the+people+fear+the+government,+there+is+tyranny.%22&lr=&client=firefox-a 315].</ref> ''The Federalist'', however, was the work of Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, and James Madison; it also does not contain the text of this quotation. This quotation is vaguely similar to Jefferson's comment in an 1825 letter to William Short: "Some are whigs, liberals, democrats, call them what you please. Others are tories, serviles, aristocrats, &c. The latter fear the people, and wish to transfer all power to the higher classes of society; the former consider the people as the safest depository of power in the last resort; they cherish them therefore, and wish to leave in them all the powers to the exercise of which they are competent."<ref>Jefferson to William Short, 8 January 1825. [http://oll.libertyfund.org/title/808/88488 Ford XII:?].</ref>+'''Comments:''' One source attributes this quotation to Thomas Jefferson in ''The Federalist.''<ref>Archimedes C. Articulo, ''The Experience of Philosophy'' (Manila, Philipines: Rex Book Store, 2008), [http://books.google.com/books?id=EqyBOV6NY8oC&pg=PT334&dq=%22When+the+people+fear+the+government,+there+is+tyranny.%22&lr=&client=firefox-a 315].</ref> ''The Federalist'', however, was the work of Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, and James Madison; it also does not contain the text of this quotation. This quotation is vaguely similar to Jefferson's comment in an 1825 letter to William Short: "Some are whigs, liberals, democrats, call them what you please. Others are tories, serviles, aristocrats, &c. The latter fear the people, and wish to transfer all power to the higher classes of society; the former consider the people as the safest depository of power in the last resort; they cherish them therefore, and wish to leave in them all the powers to the exercise of which they are competent."<ref>Jefferson to William Short, 8 January 1825. [http://oll.libertyfund.org/title/808/88488 Ford XII:?].</ref> To date however, the most likely source of this quotation appears to be a series of debates on socialism published in 1914, in which John Basil Barnhill said, "Where the people fear the government you have tyranny. Where the government fears the people you have liberty."
==Footnotes== ==Footnotes==

Current revision

Quotation: "When governments fear the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny."

Variations:

  1. "When governments fear the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny. The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to keep and bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government."
  2. "Does the government fear us? Or do we fear the government? When the people fear the government, tyranny has found victory. The federal government is our servant, not our master!"
  3. “When the people fear the government, that's tyranny; when the government fears the people, that's freedom.”

Sources consulted: Searching on the phrase "fear the people," "government fear us," "fear the government," "tyranny has found victory," and "government is our servant"

  1. Papers of Thomas Jefferson Digital Edition
  2. Monticello website
  3. Ford's Works of Thomas Jefferson
  4. UVA EText Jefferson Digital Archive: Jeffersonian Cyclopedia, Thomas Jefferson on Politics and Government, Texts by or to Thomas Jefferson from the Modern English Collection
  5. Thomas Jefferson Retirement Papers
  6. Quotable Jefferson, ed. Kaminski (searching under "tyranny")
  7. Bartleby.com


Earliest known appearance in print: 1914[1] [2]

Earliest known appearance in print, attributed to Thomas Jefferson: 1994[3]

Other attributions: Samuel Adams, Thomas Paine

Status: We have not found any evidence that Thomas Jefferson said or wrote, "When governments fear the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny," or any of its listed variations.

Comments: One source attributes this quotation to Thomas Jefferson in The Federalist.[4] The Federalist, however, was the work of Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, and James Madison; it also does not contain the text of this quotation. This quotation is vaguely similar to Jefferson's comment in an 1825 letter to William Short: "Some are whigs, liberals, democrats, call them what you please. Others are tories, serviles, aristocrats, &c. The latter fear the people, and wish to transfer all power to the higher classes of society; the former consider the people as the safest depository of power in the last resort; they cherish them therefore, and wish to leave in them all the powers to the exercise of which they are competent."[5] To date however, the most likely source of this quotation appears to be a series of debates on socialism published in 1914, in which John Basil Barnhill said, "Where the people fear the government you have tyranny. Where the government fears the people you have liberty."

Footnotes

  1. John Basil Barnhill, Barnhill-Tichenor Debate on Socialism, As It Appeared in the National Rip-Saw. Saint Louis, Mo.: The National Rip-Saw Pub. Co., 1914, 34.
  2. To establish the earliest appearance of this phrase in print, the following sources were searched for the phrase, "When governments fear the people, there is liberty": Google Books, Google Scholar, Amazon.com, Internet Archive, JSTOR, American Broadsides and Ephemera, American History and Culture Online: Sabin Americana, 1500-1926, Early American Imprints, Series I: Evans (1639-1800), Early American Imprints, Series II: Shaw-Shoemaker (1801-1819), Eighteenth Century Collections Online, The Making of the Modern World: The Goldsmiths'-Kress Library of Economic Literature, America's Historical Newspapers, 19th Century United States Newspapers, American Founding Era Collection.
  3. Gyeorgos Ceres Hatonn, It's All in the Game: Butterflies, Mind Control--The Razor's Edge (Phoenix Source Distributors, 1994), 214.
  4. Archimedes C. Articulo, The Experience of Philosophy (Manila, Philipines: Rex Book Store, 2008), 315.
  5. Jefferson to William Short, 8 January 1825. Ford XII:?.

Further Sources